Maher Supports Call on Controversial Covid-19 Nursing Home Directive

Assemblyman Brian Maher (R,C-Walden) has joined Assemblyman Josh Jensen and fellow lawmakers in calling on Governor Kathy Hochul and the New York State Department of Health (DOH) to provide answers regarding the controversial March 25, 2020 COVID-19 nursing home directive and the state's handling of nursing home admissions during the pandemic.

In a letter addressed to Governor Hochul and DOH Commissioner Dr. James McDonald, lawmakers are demanding clarification on whether the directive, which prohibited nursing homes from denying admission or readmission to individuals with confirmed or suspected COVID-19, was consistent with federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) guidance.

The letter cites findings from a congressional investigation that questioned whether the state's nursing home directive was consistent with federal guidance and raised concerns about the accuracy of the state's reporting of nursing home deaths. These findings have renewed calls for a full accounting of the decisions made by state officials during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“More than six years have passed, and families who lost loved ones in New York's nursing homes are still waiting for answers,” said Maher. “These families deserve transparency, accountability and the truth about the decisions that were made during one of the darkest periods in our state's history. The state cannot continue to deflect responsibility or hide behind previous administrations. The Department of Health owes these families a clear explanation, and I am proud to stand alongside my colleagues in demanding those answers.”

During the pandemic, Maher served as supervisor of the Town of Montgomery, where he witnessed firsthand the devastating impact of COVID-19 on residents and families at Montgomery Nursing Home. Loved ones were left helpless, unable to visit or advocate for their family members, as state policies and a lack of leadership put some of New York's most vulnerable residents at risk.

The letter specifically requests that DOH clarify whether it maintains that the March 25 directive was consistent with CMS guidance. If so, lawmakers are asking the department to identify the precise federal language supporting that determination. If not, they are calling on the department to acknowledge that the directive was not based on such federal guidance.

The lawmakers also raise concerns about the department's response to families seeking answers, emphasizing that changes in leadership do not eliminate the agency's responsibility to the public.

“Accountability does not have an expiration date,” Maher continued. “I saw firsthand the heartbreak and devastation experienced by families at Montgomery Nursing Home. Those families were denied the opportunity to be with their loved ones when they needed them most, and the pain of those losses has not gone away. The families of the more than 15,000 New Yorkers who lost their lives in nursing homes during the pandemic deserve more than excuses and unanswered questions. We owe it to them to ensure the truth is brought to light and that those responsible for these decisions are held accountable.”

Maher reiterated his support for continued transparency surrounding New York's COVID-19 nursing home policies and called on the Hochul administration to provide a timely and substantive response to the lawmakers' concerns.